Skip to content

Must the artist lobby like everyone else?


After attending a panel on artist economics, Lachlan Taylor thinks through the relationship between funding, politics, and models of collective action in the arts sector.

16 November 2026
Chlöe Swarbrick, Sarah Hopkinson, Eleanor Cooper, and Felixe Laing at the New Benefactors event Artist Economics, Artspace Aotearoa, October 2026. (Photo: Courtesy of Artspace Aotearoa).

A healthy crowd had assembled inside Artspace Aotearoa for the panel. Titled Artist economics: how do we keep making?, the event on 28 October was convened by Artspace Aotearoa Kaiwhakapā Communication Coordinator Felixe Laing, and featured artist Eleanor Cooper; gallerist Sarah Hopkinson, of Coastal Signs; and MP for Auckland Central Chlöe Swarbrick. This was a New Benefactors event, part of the programme Artspace Aotearoa runs aspiring to nurture a new generation of arts patrons.

I’d gone in feeling like there was more than a little comedy involved in an event about the financial precarity of a life in the arts pitched to patrons, but Laing deftly wove the kaupapa with the ethos of the New Benefactors programme – lowering the barriers to entry for arts patronage and including that expanded field of support in the crucial questions that affect the sector.

Cooper spoke first, and directly to the strategies she has cultivated for surviving a life in the arts. While I was hearing some specific approaches for the first time – living in DoC huts, or on a boat, to sidestep rent – the general thrusts were familiar, like finding work outside of the sector, and getting comfortable with a radically expanded notion of what and where might constitute a studio, and even a home. Her theme was one of being honest about the privations and limitations of this life, but how ultimately to “treat those limitations productively.” Cooper’s was a familiar, if particularly laudable, story of ingenuity in the absence of support, and I wondered how the assembled New Benefactors would receive it, having seen so often how easy it is to champion the ingenuity while glossing over the absence. 

Hopkinson started with an always-popular denunciation of sustainability discourse in the arts which, while absent from any of the promotional copy, certainly hovered over the conversation. Her two critiques were substantive: the Aotearoa art market is too small to support the number of graduates and spaces we produce, and that our arts infrastructure used to be better equipped for outward interaction, that we were once “better at export and exchange.” 

An attentive, if quiet, crowd at Artist Economics, Artspace Aotearoa, October 2026. (Photo: Courtesy of Artspace Aotearoa).

Swarbrick began with an anecdote. She recently attended an artists’ hui in Ōtautahi organised in reaction to CNZ’s underfunding of Te Waipounamu artists and organisations in their latest major funding round. Swarbrick told us that, while she expected to hear the demands of these artists, she was instead met by tales of “the trauma of funding rounds and survival”, noting that “it wasn’t clear what people actually want.” The politician suggested that artists in Aotearoa may need to “unionise, or at least collectivise” in order to have their needs met by politicians. “If you want politicians to respond to your needs, you need to organise and articulate your needs.” 

This stance didn’t preclude her from offering some possible policy options for the future: the ever-elusive basic income for the arts (as seen in Ireland), or arts funding for capital assets such as gallery or studio spaces. Swarbrick then asked, “what if we thought of arts infrastructure like roads?” The crowd nodded with enthusiasm. 

Her next and final comment turned out to be the last major word of the night: “If you think about who is winning in this system it is those who are very, very good at lobbying.” Instead of a Q&A, Laing invited the crowd to mingle and address any questions they might have to the panelists one on one. Sometimes as a writer you need to work really hard to find metaphors and sometimes you don’t. 

Swarbrick’s last suggestion stayed with me on the drive home, and a little longer. I didn’t think she meant that to be taken seriously by politicians and actually move the needle of legislative action, arts workers would need to adopt the structure and organizing ethos of Fonterra or Shane Jones’ various extractive droogies. This wouldn’t really align with her politics, or the ways in which she’s achieved change herself. But what does that leave? 

A union has always been a nonstarter in practical, material terms. Barring some future sector-wide compensation or law change, the vast majority of artists are independent contractors and so closed off from traditional routes of collective bargaining or strike action. Collectivization is then limited to advocacy and lobbying – activities that require both organization and resources to succeed in placing consistent pressure on politicians in the mode Swarbrick seemed to suggest. But as research shows the median wage of creative workers in Aotearoa is just over half that of the average New Zealander, it’s hard to imagine where the resources or time required for such pressure will arise from regardless of organizational efficiency. 

‘Arts worker’ is a pretty liberally applied appellation. Could we bring salaried workers, curators, directors, and dealers into the fold, creating a big tent collective? I’d love to see it work, though I’m cautious to recommend an organization with directly conflicting class interests and lopsided access to resources becoming a coherent and well-articulated political force. 

Here’s the weird thing. It’s not like the basic needs of artists have been going hopelessly unarticulated. The fundamentals are there, ready to be taken up. Adequately fund and reform CNZ so that funding for spaces and individual artist projects is competitive but achievable the country over. Keep politicians well out of direct funding decisions. Take the money for arts funding from literally anywhere other than gambling. What starts to get confusing, and a little frustrating, is that these positions and more have been advocated for by collective arts organizations like Arts Makers Aotearoa and, more recently and to real effect, nzveniceunredacted.

I’m really glad that Artspace Aotearoa held this conversation, in fact I’m always encouraged by any attempt to make the very real crisis of arts funding in Aotearoa visible, along with any push towards ameliorating it. What’s still kicking around in my head is a conception of political action where only by getting “very, very good” at the dark arts of lobbying will politicians ever consider our needs particularly needful. Because the truth is that, while the specifics of an artists’ basic income may be far out of reach, the most obvious and pressing adjustments are both articulated and actionable. We shouldn’t need a lobby. Leadership, both from actors within our sector and from politicians with the conviction to champion artistic labour for the labour it is, should have an impact on the legislative needle.

ADVERTISEMENT